Americans United for Separation of Church and State

Greater Phoenix Chapter

Old Home Home Contact Us Upcoming
Events
Past
Events
Photos
Videos
Church State Issues Report Church State Violations Join
Email List
Leave
Email List
Membership Donations Request
Speaker
Take
Action
Legal
Resources
Facebook Meetup Links Send Letter to Editor

                                                                                                                       

Church State Issues

McClellan: Government cant be used to intrude on private lives of women

Mar 16, 2012

East Valley Tribune

Guest Commentary by Mike McClellan

What do Justin Olsen, Justin Pierce, Frank Pratt, Cecil Ash, Steve Court, Eddie Farnsworth, John Fillmore, Tom Forese, J.D. Mesnard, and Steve Urie have in common?

Beyond being East Valley Republican legislators, they all want to use the government to intrude on the private lives of women.

They give the lie to their claim that the government which governs least governs best.

In fact, they use the government’s power to force women to reveal their medical histories to their employers. Even more, they want to allow employers to discriminate against employees who use contraception.

How did all this come about?

Glendale Representative Debbie Lesko’s HB 2625. A bill that ostensibly protects an employer’s religious freedom, in this case the right to deny employees contraception coverage in employer-provided health insurance.

But Lesko’s bill goes far beyond that. And all of the Republicans listed above voted for it. Republicans who like to complain about Big Government. I guess they were against Big Government before they were for it.

Lesko’s legislation requires a woman whose employer’s insurance plan doesn’t provide elective contraception to prove to said employer that the contraception the woman applies for is medically necessary.

So a woman with a medical condition that requires contraception — and some do — must reveal to her employer just what that condition is.

If, that is, she wants the insurance to cover her.

Which means the employer becomes privy to information that’s none of his business.

But not in Ms. Lesko’s mind. No in her world, a woman’s medical condition is just between the woman, her doctor ... and her employer.

Lesko’s Law goes even further. Read section 7 of the bill’s summary, which says the bill “eliminates language that prohibits an employer from discriminating against an employee who independently chooses to obtain insurance coverage or prescriptions for contraception from another source.”

From “another source?” Excuse me. How is that employer supposed to even know? Does Ms. Lesko’s bill allow for an employer to inquire? And what does she mean by allowing an employer to “discriminate” against an employee who gets birth control from an outside source? Who knows, because the legislation doesn’t define it.

No problem for our East Valley Republicans, though, as they voted lockstep with the rest of the House Republicans, passing the bill and moving it to the Senate.

Ms. Lesko says this is all about the First Amendment: “I believe we live in America. We don’t live in the Soviet Union. So, government should not be telling the organizations or mom-and-pop employers to do something against their moral beliefs.”

Apparently, Ms. Lesko’s reading of the Constitution ends with the First Amendment. She might want to read on a bit. Say, maybe to the Ninth and Tenth Amendments.

That would, of course, require Ms. Lesko and her band of spies to actually read the document. Fat chance.

Mike McClellan is a Gilbert resident and former English teacher at Dobson High School in Mesa.

Complain about this violation of Church & State to:

Debbie Lesko
District 9
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 222
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-5413
(602)417-3109 Fax

dlesko@azleg.gov


Justin Olsen
District 19
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 341
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602) 926-5288
(602)417-3161 Fax Fax

jolson@azleg.gov


Justin Pierce
District 19
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 124
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-5495
(602)417-3019 Fax

jpierce@azleg.gov


Frank Pratt
District 23
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 115
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-5761
(602)417-3023 Fax

fpratt@azleg.gov


Cecil P. Ash
District 18
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 313
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-3160
(602)417-3151 Fax

cash@azleg.gov


Steve Court
District 18
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 206
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-4467
(602)417-3018 Fax

scourt@azleg.gov


Eddie Farnsworth
District 22
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 222
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-5735
(602)417-3122Fax

efarnsworth@azleg.gov


John Fillmore
District 23
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 331
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602) 926-3012
(602)417-3123 Fax

jfillmore@azleg.gov


Tom Forese
District 21
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 113
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-5168
(602)417-3021 Fax

tforese@azleg.gov


Javan "J.D." Mesnard
District 21
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 342
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-4481
(602)417-3152 Fax

jmesnard@azleg.gov


Steve Urie
District 22
House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Room 337
Phoenix, AZ 85007
(602)926-4136
(602)417-3222 Fax

surie@azleg.gov