Americans United for Separation of Church and State

Greater Phoenix Chapter

Old Home Home Contact Us Upcoming
Events
Past
Events
Photos
Videos
Church State Issues Report Church State Violations Join
Email List
Leave
Email List
Membership Donations Request
Speaker
Take
Action
Legal
Resources
Facebook Meetup Links Send Letter to Editor

                                                                                                                       

Church State Issues

Proposed law offers religious leaders exemption from conducting gay marriage services

Jan 5, 2014

By: Rep. Steve Montenegro of Litchfield Park

East Valley Tribune

I don't have a problem with this. Slavery has been illegal for years (well except for when it comes to the government making slaves out of convicted criminals, which is the ONLY exception in the 13th Amendment).

If a minister doesn't want to perform gay marriages or any other marriages he certainly shouldn't be force to perform one.

On the other hand if a gay couple wants to get married there are certainly many other people would would be willing to perform the ceremony.

When I read the Arizona law it seems that just about ANYONE is legally allowed to perform a marriage per ARS 25-124.B

25-124. Persons authorized to perform marriage ceremony; definition

A. The following are authorized to solemnize marriages between persons who are authorized to marry:

1. Duly licensed or ordained clergymen.

SNIP

B. For the purposes of this section, "licensed or ordained clergymen" includes ministers, elders or other persons who by the customs, rules and regulations of a religious society or sect are authorized or permitted to solemnize marriages or to officiate at marriage ceremonies.

On the other hand I suspect that this proposed bill isn't about people rights, but rather an attempt by Rep. Steve Montenegro of Litchfield Park to get the votes of the folks who hate gay.


Proposed law offers religious leaders exemption from conducting gay marriage services

Posted: Friday, January 3, 2014 6:30 pm

By Howard Fischer, Capitol Media Services

A state lawmaker who also is a pastor unveiled legislation Friday designed to protect him and others religious leaders from being forced to marry same-sex couples.

The proposal by Rep. Steve Montenegro, R-Litchfield Park, would make it illegal for government to “require a minister to solemnize a marriage inconsistent with a minister's sincerely held religious beliefs.” It also would spell out that churches need not recognize or facilitate marriages inconsistent with their tenets.

Montenegro acknowledged there is currently no danger of such a mandate.

The U.S. Supreme Court did require the federal government to recognize gay nuptials performed in states where legal. But that ruling left untouched Arizona's own constitutional ban on such unions, whether performed here or elsewhere.

Montenegro said, though, that federal courts have increasingly overturned state bans, most recently in Utah.

More concerning, he pointed to a lawsuit filed there against the Church of Latter-day Saints accusing it and the state of conspiring to deprive gays of the freedom to marry. So Montenegro wants to do what he can to cut off that possibility before it occurs here.

“There are many things that both of us would say, ‘Wow. I didn't see that coming,’” Montenegro said. He said the legislation is a preemptive strike.

The proposed language is being added to existing state laws which already make it illegal for the government to “substantially burden” anyone's free exercise of religion. Under those laws, the only exception is when the legislation or regulation furthers some “compelling governmental interest” and is “the least restrictive means” of furthering that interest.

Montenegro said he is trying to keep his own measure as narrow as possible.

For example, it spells out that the protections against having to recognize a same-sex marriage does not extend to hospitals, hotels, restaurants, businesses or other places of public accommodation. That is designed from it becoming a weapon in legal fights similar to one in New Mexico where that state's high court ruled that a commercial wedding photographer could not refuse to take pictures of a same-sex wedding.

“We're not trying to go out and pick a fight,” Montenegro said. He said nothing in the legislation would bar a pastor, minister, rabbi or other religious leader from voluntarily presiding over a same-sex marriage, though under current Arizona law it would not be recognized by the state.

Montenegro conceded that the entire effort could prove meaningless even if he gets it approved by the Legislature and signed by Gov. Jan Brewer: A court could still rule the measure unconstitutional. But Montenegro said he still thinks the effort is worthwhile.

“As representatives of the people here in Arizona, we want to make sure we're doing our part to protect the religious freedoms of pastors, ministers, and the churches,” he said.

Montenegro's bio says he has a degree in theology and currently serves as associate and youth pastor at the Surprise Apostolic Assembly.